1977
Moose Cook, Pitcher - NAIA Second Team
Marty Scott, Third Baseman - NAIA Honorable Mention

1978
Moose Cook, Pitcher - NAIA Second Team

1979
Kevin Smith, Outfielder - NAIA Honorable Mention

1980
Orie Mason, First Baseman - NAIA Honorable Mention

1983
Alan Burt, Shortstop - NAIA Honorable Mention
Mark Lawrence, Designated Hitter - NAIA Honorable Mention

1985
Ray Hydes, Catcher - NAIA Honorable Mention
Lester Lancaster, Pitcher - NAIA Honorable Mention
James Picha, Third Baseman - NAIA Scholar Athlete

1986
Colin Charland, Pitcher - NAIA Honorable Mention
David Jefferson, Outfielder - NAIA Second Team
James Picha, Pitcher - NAIA Scholar Athlete

1987
Javan Reagans, Outfielder - NAIA Second Team

1988
Mark Brown, Third Baseman - NAIA Second Team
Jay Gravens, Pitcher - NAIA Second Team

1990
Mike Rodriguez, Second Baseman - NAIA First Team
Chan Yun, Third Baseman

• NAIA First Team
• NAIA National Player of the Year

1991
Jerome McGary, Designated Hitter - NAIA Honorable Mention

1992
Dale Baggett, Third Baseman - NAIA Honorable Mention
Steve Gann, Second Baseman - NAIA Honorable Mention
Phil Varrichio, Outfielder - NAIA Honorable Mention

1993
Steve Gann, Second Baseman - NAIA First Team
Ralph Denman, Designated Hitter - NAIA Honorable Mention

1994
Rick Ortiz, Pitcher - NAIA Honorable Mention
Jason Parsons, First Baseman - NAIA Second Team
Chris Spenrath, Pitcher - NAIA Honorable Mention

1995
Scott Harp, Outfielder - NAIA Second Team
Jason Parsons, First Baseman - Honorable Mention

1996
Ryan Andersen, Shortstop - NAIA First Team
Scott Harp, Outfielder -

• NAIA First Team
• NAIA Scholar Athlete
• 3rd Team GTE Academic

1997
Allen Chase, Designated Hitter - NAIA Scholar Athlete
Cade Griffis, Outfielder - NAIA Honorable Mention
Brandon Harper, Catcher - NAIA Second Team

1998
Lew Ford, Outfielder - NAIA First Team
Cameron White, Catcher - NAIA First Team

1999
Lew Ford, Outfielder - NAIA Honorable Mention
Cody Sundbeck, Pitcher - NAIA Honorable Mention

2000
Steven Berry, Second Baseman - NAIA Academic All-American
Jon Browder, Pitcher - NAIA First Team
Nathan Cook, Third Baseman - NAIA Honorable Mention
Eric Darjean, Center Field - Gold Glove Award - Best Defensive Player

2001
Steven Berry, Second Base

• NAIA Second Team
• NAIA Academic All-American
• 3rd Team GTE Academic All-American

2002
Josh Causey, Shortstop - NAIA First Team
Cody Sadler, Outfield - NAIA Second Team
Chad Shindle, First Base - NAIA Second Team
Tommy Clark, Pitcher - NAIA All-American

2003
Drew Holder, Outfield – NCCAA MVP
Drew Noss, Infield – NCCAA Honorable Mention
Blair Robinson, Infield – NCCAA Honorable Mention
Cody Montgomery, Infield – NCCAA Honorable Mention

2004
Stuart Sutherland, Pitcher – NCCAA MVP
Jeff Gilmore, Pitcher

• NCCAA All-American
• NCCAA Pitcher of the Year

Ryan Olivo, Outfield – NCCAA All-American
Ben Zobrist, Shortstop – NCCAA All-American

2005
Drew Holder, Outfield - NCCAA All-American

2006
Drew Holder, Outfield

• Louisville Slugger First Team All-American
• American Baseball Coaches Association Second Team All-American
• NCCAA All-American

Cody Montgomery, Infielder - NCCAA All-American
Rodney Brantley, Pitcher - NCCAA All-American

2007
Austin Knight, Shortstop 

• Collegiate Baseball Louisville Slugger Freshman All-American
• Ping Baseball Freshman All-American

2008
Chris Haney, Pitcher

• Collegiate Baseball Louisville Slugger Freshman All-American